Seniors Flock to Medicare Advantage as Supplemental Insurance Rates Rise

Jan 8, 2021

A new study shows the cost of Medicare Advantage premiums decreasing, while Medicare supplements increase, leaving many wondering if they really need supplemental insurance with Medicare.

Prescott, United States - January 8, 2021 /PressCable/ —

Early estimates from new MedicareWire research shows that 2021 Medicare Advantage enrollments could be up by as much as 5.5 percent over 2020, a direct result of the increasing cost of Medicare supplement insurance, researchers said. At the same time, the annual out-of-pocket cap on Medicare Advantage plans increased by $850, putting more seniors at risk of high medical bills. The researchers found that as many as half of all 2021 Medicare Advantage plan enrollees will be in an HMO plan with an out-of-pocket maximum of $7,550, leading many to wonder if these supplemental plans are worth it.

More information can be found at https://medicarewire.com/medigap/are-medicare-supplement-plans-worth-it/

The increase in Medicare Advantage enrollment is a direct result of lower premiums on Medicare Advantage plans and increasing premiums on Medicare supplements. Since 2017, the average monthly premium on private health plans has dropped by more than 34 percent. 2021 plans have the lowest average monthly premium since 2007.

With Medicare supplement insurance rates climbing, many Original Medicare beneficiaries are comparing the monthly cost of coverage with HMO and PPO plans because the private health insurance option appears to cost less. “Our fear is that many seniors will get into financial trouble by switching to Medicare Advantage,” says David Bynon, founder at MedicareWire. “What most people don’t take into account, particularly new retirees is that many healthcare costs, especially hospitalization, can cost a lot more with Medicare Advantage.”

To help Medicare beneficiaries understand their true costs in Medicare and the type of insurance that will work best for them, MedicareWire offers a rate analysis and coverage service. The service was designed to help seniors and people with disabilities find a plan and insurance carrier with the lowest-cost plan available in their area that will meet their needs.

Kaiser Family Foundation research confirms the MedicareWire researcher’s claim that Medicare Advantage plans can be quite costly for some people, particularly those with chronic health conditions. What Kaiser discovered is that about 50 percent of beneficiaries enrolled in Medicare Advantage would have higher healthcare costs than those with Original Medicare for a 5-day hospital stay.

Medicare supplements, which pay some of the gaps in Original Medicare, including deductibles, copays, and coinsurance, are the premium option for seniors. Unlike HMO and PPO plans, there are few restrictions with Original Medicare and a supplement. But, the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services’ official literature, the “Medicare & You” handbook, tends to favor Medicare Advantage plans by over-selling annual limits, appeal rights, and statements that downplay Medicare Advantage issues.

“People frequently ask me are Medicare supplement plans worth it?”, says Bynon. “My answer is nearly always the same. You can’t predict when you will get critically ill or have a serious accident. But you can predict your healthcare costs with Original Medicare and a Medigap policy. So, yes, they are worth it.”

For healthy seniors, who rarely use healthcare services, Medicare Advantage offers excellent cost savings. But, when you come down with a chronic illness that requires regular care, including periods of hospitalization and skilled nursing for recovery, the bills stack up very fast. Many people simply are not prepared for the costs.

MedicareWire’s researchers are quick to point out that many Medicare Advantage plans lure people in with extra benefits, like prescription drug coverage, dental, vision, and hearing, and they appear to lower to have costs. But, when you dig deeper you quickly discover that most plans with zero-dollar premiums have high out-of-pocket limits, high copays, and the additional benefits have strict limits. Most dental coverage, as an example, is limited to $500 per year and does not cover all services.

All Medicare Advantage plans are required to publish a “Summary of Benefits” document that explains in reasonable detail what a plan offers and the costs members pay for all services. “Unfortunately, it’s nearly impossible to find the plan benefit documents for many plans. I have no idea why some plans make it so difficult,” says Bynon. “This is just one of the reasons that MedicareWire offers downloadable PDF files with plan cost details.”

One of the reasons it is so difficult to compare the cost of Medicare Advantage plans with Original Medicare and supplemental insurance is that it is impossible to put Medicare Advantage coverage into a chart as you can with Medigap plans. A comparison program is needed to assist people in making the best choice based on their personal health and financial situation.

Contact Info:
Name: David W Bynon
Email: Send Email
Organization: MedicareWire
Address: 101 W Goodwin Street Unit 2487, Prescott, AZ 86302, United States
Phone: +1-855-266-4865
Website: https://MedicareWire.com

Source: PressCable

Release ID: 88992748

More News

Trump puts himself on the ballot
Sep 17, 2026
Trump puts himself on the ballot

President Donald Trump at a rally in Gastonia, North Carolina, on September 16, 2026. | Brendan Smialowski/AFP via Getty Images This story appeared in The Logoff, a daily newsletter that helps you stay informed about the Trump administration without letting political news take over your life. Subscribe here. Welcome to The Logoff: With fewer than 50 days until the midterm elections, President Donald Trump is hitting the campaign trail.  What’s happening? Trump was in North Carolina last night for his first major post-primary season rally of the 2026 midterms (setting aside the GOP’s unusual midterm convention last week, which wasn’t not a Trump rally).  Republican Michael Whatley will face former North Carolina Gov. Roy Cooper in November for an open US Senate seat. Speaking near Charlotte, Trump urged voters to “pretend I’m on the ticket, because essentially I am.” It’s becoming a familiar refrain for the president, but not necessarily a promising one — polls suggest Trump is deeply unpopular with voters right now, more likely to drag a ticket down than boost it. How else is Trump getting involved in the midterms? Last week, we noted that Trump was beginning to spend from his vast super PAC account to support Republican candidates. Now, we’re getting a better idea of what that spending looks like: As of earlier this week, Trump’s MAGA Inc. super PAC and related entities had booked ads to the tune of $138 million, a number that could continue to grow. MAGA Inc. has around $400 million in the bank, though as the Washington Post reported earlier this month, Trump has a long list of other things he could choose to spend that money on instead of the midterms (such as legal fees, travel, or even his eventual presidential library). Will it make a difference? It’s a whole lot of money. But with not much time left until voters go to the polls and some mail-in ballots already going out — North Carolina voters began receiving theirs earlier this month — the map is looking fairly dire for Republican hopes.  Trump, meanwhile, isn’t doing himself any favors. The fuel shortages caused by the Iran war are only getting worse, as my colleague Caitlin Dewey explained today. Polls suggest he’s picked the wrong side of the AI issue. And voters are still extremely mad about inflation. And with that, it’s time to log off… It’s not every day we get to write about a new cat — in fact, it’s the first time in more than 100 years. But that’s just what scientists found in the Bolivian Yungas Forest, according to a new study published today. The cat, Leopardus tilcayo, is a type of tiger cat, smaller than your average house cat. It’s also quite cute, and you can see pictures of it here. Thanks for reading, have a great evening, and we’ll see you back here tomorrow!

YOUR NEWS, OUR NETWORK.

Do you have Great News you want to tell the world?

Be it updates about your business or your community, you can make sure that it’s heard by submitting your story to our network reaching hundreds of news sites across 6 verticals.

Expert Features

The Expert Features reports on the issues and the world’s everyday news. Handled by experts in different niches, you will find different subjects and perspectives.